In the November/December 2014 issue of Biblical Archaeology Review, Andrew Lincoln examines New Testament accounts of Jesus’ birth. The idea that Jesus was born of a virgin is firmly established in Christian creeds and the subject of many Nativity plays and Christmas carols. How did ancient peoples understand the nature of conception? Did their understanding conflict with the idea of a virgin birth? BAS editors have compiled a special collection of Bible Review articles exploring virgin birth stories, early Christian views about Jesus’ birth and seminal emission in the Hebrew Bible.

Scroll down to read a summary of these articles.

Matthew and Luke in their gospels plainly state that Jesus was divinely conceived by the Holy Spirit. For those who believe in the inerrancy of the New Testament, no further support for the virgin birth is needed. But others, such as American founding father Thomas Paine, observed that just because Matthew relates that Joseph said that an angel told him that Mary “was with child without any cohabitation with a man” was no proof at all. Perhaps neither position addresses the complexities of the Bible’s virgin birth stories, says J. Edward Barrett in “Can Scholars Take the Virgin Birth of Jesus Seriously?” Probing the virgin birth stories, Barrett discusses problems of Hebrew/Greek translation, the contexts of the famous prophecies in the Book of Isaiah, and father-son relationships in the Jewish and Hellenistic worlds in Bible times.

J. Edward Barrett’s Bible Review article “Can Scholars Take the Virgin Birth of Jesus Seriously?” produced an avalanche of letters from readers, many offended by the New Testament professor’s academic examination of Jesus’ virgin birth. Twenty-seven readers’ letters can be read in “Readers Reply: Avalanche of Letters Challenges Controversial Article.”

The flurry of letters received in response to Barrett’s Bible Review article prompted James E. Crouch to examine early Christian views about Jesus’ origin. In “How Early Christians Viewed the Birth of Jesus,” Crouch finds that various understandings of Jesus’ birth were current in the early Church. At one time, for example, the pre-existence of Christ, rather than the mode of his birth, was considered by many Christians to be the crucial hallmark of their faith. Handling theological issues and literary concerns with equal aplomb, Crouch also details the ways in which the infancy narratives in the Gospels echo birth stories in the Hebrew Bible.

“Now faith is the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen” begins the hymn of faith in Hebrews 11. The hymn goes on to praise several Hebrew Bible figures for their faith, among them the matriarch Sarah. But the hymn uses an extremely puzzling phrase regarding Sarah: When translated literally, it says Sarah received the power to emit semen. To avoid the problem, some scholars translate the phrase to mean that she received the power to conceive or that the phrase was meant to apply to Abraham. Pieter W. van der Horst confronts the question “Did Sarah Have a Seminal Emission?” and, using classical Greek, rabbinic and early Christian ideas regarding conception, shows that the phrase in Hebrews means exactly what it says.


Can Scholars Take the Virgin Birth Seriously?
Bible Review, October 1988 By J. Edward Barrett

010 Three clear arguments support belief in the virgin birth1 of Jesus. The first is textual. Both Matthew and Luke state clearly that Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit, without the aid of a human father: Matthew Luke “Now the birth of Jesus Christ took place in this way. When his mother […]

How Early Christians Viewed the Birth of Jesus
Bible Review, October 1991 By James E. Crouch

“Can Scholars Take the Virgin Birth Seriously?” BR 04:05, by J. Edward Barrett, produced more letters to the editor than any other article ever published in this magazine. Of the 27 letters printed, only two suggested that Barrett’s exploration of the subject had any merit whatever. Such a response leads me to believe that […]

Did Sarah Have a Seminal Emission?
Bible Review, February 1992 By Pieter W. van der Horst

The anonymous Epistle to the Hebrews contains a justly famous panegyric to faith (see the sidebar to this article). In a series of sentences that begins “By faith,” the letter recites the accomplishments of ancient heroes—Abel, Enoch, Noah; then Abraham—and Sarah. What did Sarah accomplish by faith? The Greek contains a difficult term. Taken […]


Readers Reply
Bible Review, February 1989

Avalanche of Letters Challenges Controversial Article